Peanut Butter & Co., on Sullivan Street, is one of my absolute favorite spots in the city. I first discovered it in junior high, when my best friend Arielle and I would head down to the Village on Saturdays in search of the perfect costume jewelry from Ziggy’s (which has since closed), loose tea from Aphrodisia, and sparkly eye makeup from Ricky’s, and would inevitably end up at Peanut Butter & Co. eating Elvis sandwiches (served alongside tall glasses of cold milk and carrot sticks).